Past Events - 2004 Tariff/Pricing Committee Meeting
February 23-24, 2004
Co-Hosted by
National Electricity and Heat Regulatory Authority of Romania (ANRE)
National Natural Gas Regulatory Authority of Romania (ANRGN)
Energy Regulators Regional Association (ERRA)
National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC)
Sponsored by
U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID)
Bulletin
Agenda
Participant List
Materials
Bulletin
The Energy Regulators Regional Association (ERRA) held its Winter Tariff/Pricing Committee Meeting on February 23-24, 2004 in Bucharest, Romania. The meeting was co-hosted by the National Electricity and Heat Regulatory Authority of Romania (ANRE), the National Natural Gas Regulatory Authority of Romania (ANRGN), the Energy Regulators Regional Association (ERRA), and the U.S. National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC), with funding provided by the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID).
Representatives from 15 of ERRA’s 19 Full Members participated on the meeting, including Albania, Armenia, Bulgaria, Croatia, Estonia, Hungary, Lithuania, Moldova, Mongolia, Poland, Romania, Russian Federation, Slovakia, Turkey, and Ukraine. ERRA Associate members joint the meeting from Mongolia, Romanian Gas Regulator. As Observers, representative from the newly founded Regulatory Commission of Macedonia and Dr. Jamshid Heidarian, Senior Energy Advisor, Energy and Infrastructure Division, Bureau for Europe and Eurasia, USAID took part on the meeting. NARUC representatives included Ms. Sandra Waldstein, Senior Policy Advisor, Vermont Public Service Board and Mr. Mark Beyer, Deputy Chief Economist New Jersey Board of Public Utilities. The Winter Meeting of the ERRA’s Standing Committee, which lasted for two-days, begun with traditional country updates presentations on the Regulatory Tariff News of the ERRA member-countries focusing on the news in the energy sector and tariff regulation. ERRA members introduced the regulatory situation in their country in a 15 minutes’ presentation updating on the latest changes since the previous meeting.
Further on, the Committee discussed and approved the Issue Paper on “Determination of Tariffs for Ancillary services” written by Ms. Sandra Waldstein, U.S., and Mr. Ainars Cunculis, Latvia. The issue paper included a comprehensive glossary of ancillary terms with the aim to clear of existing different understanding of terms used in the energy sector worldwide. The paper detailed the types, pricing and charges of ancillary services in the EU and ERRA countries. Prior to this paper, the ERRA Secretariat sent out two questionnaires to every participant in order to obtain information of the applicable ancillary services in the ERRA region. Appendixes to the paper focused on the UCTE terms, U.S. examples and state of ancillary services.
After that a case study was presented by Mr. Ede Treso, Hungary, about how to “Supply quality standards and regulation from HEO’s respect”. The study was a second-round discussion, which were started during the Fall meeting in 2003. Hungary has taken a leading role in introducing quality standard regulation and benchmarking, and the study detailed incentive/penalty mechanisms’ reflection on prices.
During the afternoon of the 2nd day, the Committee lead discussions of the Work Plan for 2004, clarifying future tasks and new projects, including a Workshop dedicated to gas tariff issues, and future topics such as the joint meeting with the Licensing Committee on Stranded Cost, Performance Evaluation, ERRA Tariff Data Collection of Average Electricity and Gas Prices. At the end of the meeting, Ms. Viola Dozsa, ERRA briefed the committee members on recent and future planned ERRA activities and on the possible dates, topics and location of the upcoming meetings.
By Viola Dozsa, ERRA Program Manager Agenda
Monday, February 23, 2004
09:00 Welcoming Comments • Vice-President Horia Bogdan, National Electricity and Heat Regulatory Authority of Romania • Commissioner Florin Gugu, Romanian Electricity and Heat Regulatory Authority, Chairman, Tariff/Pricing Committee • Dr. Jamshid Heidarian, Senior Energy Advisor, Energy and Infrastructure Division, Bureau for Europe and Eurasia, USAID
09:15 Introduction of new Committee Members and NARUC staff
09:20 Presentations: “Regulatory Tariff News updates” Each Committee Member will be requested to give a max. 10-15 min. presentation (2-3 slides) • Mr. Kastriot Sulka, Albania • Mr. Robert Tsovyan, Armenia • Commissioner Svetla Todorova, Bulgaria • Commissioner Ivona Štritof, Croatia • Ms. Külli Haab, Estonia
10:45 Coffee break
11:00 Presentations: “Regulatory Tariff News updates’ cont’d • Commissioner Demur Chomakhidze, Georgia • Mr. Ede Tresó, Hungary • Ms. Danna Tokubaeva, Kazakhstan • Mr. Bekbo Mamatbekov, Kyrgyz Republic • Mr. Ainars Cunculis, Latvia • Ms. Aistija Zubaviciute, Lithuania
12:30 Lunch
14:00 Presentations: “Regulatory Tariff News updates’ cont’d • Ms. Lidia Zestrea, Moldova • Mr. Gombosuren Battushig, Mongolia • Ms. Beata Telecka, Poland • Commissioner Florin Gugu and Mrs. Marcela Oltean, Romania • Mr. Konstantin Zubanov, Russian Federation • Mr. Karol Dvorák, Slovakia
15:30 Coffee break
15:45 Presentations: “Regulatory Tariff News updates’ cont’d • Mr. Çetin Kayabaş, Turkey • Commissioner Yuriy Kyyashko, Ukraine
16:15 Conclusion of the Meeting
Tuesday, February 24, 2004
09:00 Issue Paper discussion & approval: Determination of tariffs for ancillary services • Ms. Sandra Waldstein, Vermont Public Service Commission, USA • Mr. Ainars Cunculis, Latvia, PUC • Discussions & Committees Approval
10:30 Coffee break
10:45 Case Study: Supply Quality Standards and Regulation from HEO’s respect • Mr. Ede Tresó, Senior Advisor, Pricing Section, HEO-Hungary • Discussions
11:45 Discussion on the Work Plan for 2004 • Commissioner Florin Gugu, Romania • Ms. Viola Dozsa, Program Manager, ERRA Secretariat Assignment of roles/responsibilities to committee members; Define topics of the next meeting; Define scope of work of the Gas Tariff Workshop and countries.
12:30 Lunch
14:00 Issue Paper: Performance Evaluation Committee’s discussion on identifying list of subtopics, specifying the meaning of the Performance Evaluation, and team leaders of the Issue Paper.
14:30 Discussions of the Tariff Statistics Data of ERRA Database on Average Electricity and Gas Prices Next data collection is due by March 20, for data for 3rd and 4th quarters of 2003, annual data for 2003 • Discussion on Database improvements, new format development
15:30 Committee Discussions on the Joint Committee Meeting with the Licensing/Competition Committee on the Stranded Cost
16:15 Update on Recent and Future ERRA Activities Ms. Viola Dozsa, Program Manager, ERRA Secretariat
16:30 Meeting Concludes
Participant List
Albania Electricity Regulatory Authority (ERE) Tel: (355 42) 69590; Fax: (355 42) 322 45 Mr. Kastriot Sulka, Head of Tariff Department
Armenia Natural Monopoly Regulatory Commission of the Republic of Armenia (NMRC) Tel: (374 1) 522 522; Fax: (374 1) 525 563 Mr. Robert Tsovyan, Consultant
Bulgaria State Energy Regulatory Commission (SERC) Tel: (359 2) 5490-503; Fax: (359 2) 988 8782 Commissioner Svetla Todorova
Croatia Croatian Energy Regulatory Council (CERC) Tel: (385 1) 6326 230, Fax: (385 1) 6326 261 Commissioner Ivona Stritof
Estonia Energy Market Inspectorate Tel: (372 6) 201 921; Fax: (372 6) 201 932 Mrs. Külli Haab, Senior Expert
Georgia Georgian National Energy Regulatory Commission (GNERC) Tel: (995 32) 253 395, or 253 396 Fax: (995 32) 253 690 Commissioner Demur Chomakhidze
Hungary Hungarian Energy Office (HEO) Tel: (361) 459 7701; Fax: (361) 459 7701 Mr. Ede Treso, Senior Advisor Pricing Department
Kazakhstan Agency for Regulation of Natural Monopolies, Protection of Competition (ANMR) Tel: (7 3172) 334-250; Fax: fax: (7 3172) 215-473 Ms. Danna Tokubaeva, Head, Department of Regulation of Natural Monopolies in Energy
Kyrgyz Republic State Energy Agency under the Government of the Kyrgyz Republic Tel: (996 312) 423 665; Fax: (996 312) 541 895 Mr. Bekbo Jumadilovich Mamatbekov, Deputy Director
Latvia Public Utilities Commission (PUC) Tel: (371) 7097 219; Fax: (371) 7097 270 Tel: (371) 7097230; Fax: (371) 7097273 Mr. Ainars Cunculis, Head of the Energy Department
Lithuania National Control Commission for Prices and Energy in Lithuania (NCC) Tel: (370 2) 2397 824; Fax: (370 2) 235 270 Mrs. Aistija Zubaviciute, Senior Specialist of the Electricity Department
Moldova National Energy Regulatory Agency (ANRE) Tel: (373 2) 278025; Fax: (373 2) 224698; Mrs. Lidia Zestrea, Head of Tariff Policy and Economic Analysis Department
Poland Electricity Regulatory Authority (ERA) Tel: (48 22) 66 16 205, Fax: (48 22) 661 62 19 Mrs. Beata Telecka - Szkurłat, Expert at the Department of Tariffs
Romania Romanian Electricity and Heat Regulatory Authority (ANRE) Tel: (401) 3032562; Fax: (401) 3124365 Commissioner Florin Gugu
Russian Federation Federal Energy Commission (FEC) Tel: (7 095) 220 4015, Fax: (7 095) 2204738 Dr. Konstantin Zubanov, Head of the Investment, Energy Saving and Regional Programs
Slovakia Regulatory Office for Network Industries Tel: (421 2) 581 00451, Fax: (421 2) 581 00479 Commissioner Karol Dvorak
Turkey Energy Market Regulatory Authority (EMRA) Tel: (90 312) 2871699, Fax: (90 312) 2878809 Mr.Cetin Kayabas, Group Head from the Electricity Department
Ukraine National Electricity Regulatory Commission (NERC) Tel: (380 44) 241 9003; Fax: (380 44) 241 90005 Commissioner Yuriy Kyyashko
ASSOCIATE ERRA MEMBERS
Romania National Natural Gas Regulatory Authority (ANRGN) Tel: (40 21) 303 38 00; Fax: (40 21) 303 38 08 Mrs. Marcela Oltean, General Director of Prices, Tariffs, Commercial Regulations, Consumers Protection Department
Mongolia Energy Regulatory Authority Tel: (976 1) 1341 430; Fax: (976 1) 1341 430 Mr. Gombosuren Battushig, Head of the Price and Tariff Department
United States National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC) Tel: (1 614) 4661846; Fax: (1 202) 8982213 Vermont Public Service Board Ms. Sandra Waldstein, Senior Policy Advisor New Jersey Board of Public Utilities Mr. Mark Beyer, Deputy Chief Economist-NJ BPU
OTHER PARTICIPANTS & OBSERVERS
Romanian Electricity and Heat Regulatory Authority (ANRE) Tel.: (40 21) 311 2244, Fax: (40 21) 312 4365 Vice-President Horia Bogdan Mr. Viorel Alicus, Head of Electricity Prices & Tariffs Office Mr. Adrian Borotea, Advisor of General Director - Prices, Tariffs & Economic Analysis Dept.
U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) Dr. Jamshid Heidarian, Senior Energy Advisor, Energy and Infrastructure Division, Bureau for Europe and Eurasia
Energy Regulators Regional Association (ERRA) Tel: (36 1) 477 0456; Fax: (36 1) 477 0455 Ms. Viola Dozsa, Program Manager, ERRA
Materials
Cunculis_Ancillary_Services_2004_eng.pdf
Waldstein_Ancillary_Services_2004_eng.pdf
Treso_Supply_Quality_Standards_2004_eng.pdf
Country Updates
Albania_Country_Updates_2004_eng.pdf
Armenia_Country_Updates_2004_eng.pdf
Bulgaria_Country_Updates_2004_eng.pdf
Croatia_Country updates_2004_eng.pdf
Estonia_Country updates_2004_eng.pdf
Georgia_Country_Updates_2004_eng.pdf
Hungary_Country_Update_2004_eng.pdf
Kyrgyz_Country_Updates_2004_eng.pdf
Latvia_Country_Update_2004_eng.pdf
Lithuania_Country_Update_2004_eng.pdf
Moldova_Country_updates_2004_eng.pdf
Poland_Country_updates_2004_eng.pdf
Romania_Country_Updates_2004_eng.pdf
Russia_Country_Updates_2004_eng.pdf
Slovakia_Country_Updates_2004_eng.pdf
Turkey_Country_Updates_2004_eng.pdf
Ukraine_Country_Updates_2004_eng.pdf
|